Nutrition Tidbit #1: Butter or a Substitute?

Nutrition TidbitNutrition Tidbit

Moderation is key to making your choice a healthy one.


Butter has be vilified over the years.  Are their any healthier options?  This article discusses a few.  One of the questions I have been asked on more than one occasion is should I use butter or not.  I am a little different than most physicians and I definitely do not agree with dietitians on this one.  I think butter is ok.  It is a heck of lot better for you than that artificial margarine stuff that used to have trans fats.  So what should I put on my toast?

Toast is one of my favorite foods for breakfast.  Toast with butter or peanut butter is a great way to start your day.  If you choose a bread that is full of fiber, it will keep you full all morning.  Follow the bread with 2-3 glasses of water and you will stay full and hydrated.  I have a few suggestions, but that is another story.

Do I eat butter when I am trying to loose weight?  The simple answer is no.  It has 100 calories per tablespoon and has more calories and saturated fat than the softer fats.  So what do I eat on my bread?  I eat either peanut butter or Brummel & Brown spread.  

What is Brummel & Brown (B&B) spread?  It is a mixture of 10% Nonfat Yogurt and 35% Vegetable Oil Spread.  Yes, it is made with yogurt.  It looks and tastes like butter.  

Brummel & Brown Spread ingredients
Brummel & Brown Spread ingredients


butter curls
fresh butter curls in dish
  1. The pros:
  • Butter is more natural than margarine. According to 21 U.S. Code 321a,   “For the purposes of the Food and Drug Act of June 30, 1906 (Thirty-fourth Statutes at Large, page 768) “butter” shall be understood to mean the food product usually known as butter, and which is made exclusively from milk or cream, or both, with or without common salt, and with or without additional coloring matter, and containing not less than 80 per centum by weight of milk fat, all tolerances having been allowed for. (Mar. 4, 1923, ch. 268, 42 Stat. 1500.)” This means that added ingredients are limited to salt and coloring agents. Some margarines contain flavoring agents, color additives, emulsifiers, preservatives, sweeteners, and water.
  • Butter is rich in the most easily absorbable form of Vitamin A necessary for thyroid and adrenal health.
  • Contains lauric acid, important in treating fungal infections and candida.
  • Butter has fat that helps the body absorb many of the healthy nutrients found in vegetables. It especially helps in the absorption of carotenoids, effective disease-fighting antioxidants present in vegetables.
  • Presence of lecithin in butter helps to enhance cholesterol metabolism.
  • Butter eases absorption of essential vitamins (A, D, E and K).
  • Vitamin D present in butter helps in absorption of calcium, which shields teeth against decay.
  • Contains arachidonic acid, which is vital for brain functioning.
  1. The cons:
  • Butter can increase levels of “bad” cholesterol and increase the risk of cardiovascular disease.
  • Butter has more calories than margarine or yogurt spread.
  • Margarine contains higher levels of healthy polyunsaturated and monounsaturated fats, and some margarines are fortified with plant sterols, which have been shown to lower blood cholesterol levels by 10 per cent (you need to eat one tablespoon of sterol-enriched spreads a day).
  • Butter contains milk fat and more readily spoils than margarine.


Margarine is a Frankenstein butter. It is completely fake and artificial. I would avoid it and have butter instead. You can see a comparison the a yogurt spread called Brummel & Brown.

Margarine vs. Brummel & Brown Spread
Margarine vs. Brummel & Brown Spread

You can click on the above image to see a larger image of comparison of the nutrition between Margarine and Brummel & Brown Spread.  The B&B has slightly less calories and I personally like the taste of it better.

Yogurt Butter vs Butter
Yogurt Butter vs Butter

You can click on the above image to see a larger image of comparison of the nutrition between Butter and Brummel & Brown Spread.  The B&B has slightly less calories and I personally like the taste of it better.

So which did I choose.  I chose B&B spread which is a butter substitute.  It taste like butter and has half the calories.  It is made with dairy so sorry vegans.

The bottom line: You need to pick a buttery or butter spread you enjoy. If you eat four times the amount to make up for the flavor or lack there of, you better of just having butter. I use B&B because I like the texture and flavor. You can lose weight with any spread as long as you watch your serving size and moderate.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

About the Author

I am a family physician who has served in the US Army. In 2016, I found myself overweight, out of shape, and unhealthy, so I made a change to improve my health. This blog is the chronology of my path to better health and what I have learned along the way.

Be the first to comment on "Nutrition Tidbit #1: Butter or a Substitute?"

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.